'For the life of me, I don’t understand,' Part II
Peter Porcupine has a different view on Metco (cobbled together from a couple emails he sent):
I think METCO IS a great idea - but after the first 15 years, I thought it should be based on income, rather than race. What does it say to Brazilian kids? Korean kids? Poor Irish kids not as ruthless/lucky as the Bulger clan?
A METCO-esque program gave Deval his start in life. That's how far it can take you. And I agree, the towns do volunteer to host the kids, and advocate for them quite selflessly.
It's just been the transportation money that sticks in my craw - I would see earnest suburban moms extolling the program at the State House, and I would wonder if they REALIZED how much it cost. And with insurance and fuel costs escalating the way they have, it has only exacerbated the situation. ...
METCO will be a volunteer program when the state stops paying 100% of the transportation costs of ferrying the students back and forth, while leaving transportation reimbursement for regional school systems - cut to zero in 2002 - languishing at 50%. (Hint - Barnstable County's 15 towns have 8 of their towns in regional districts, and no public transportation that can be used by students - just one more way the Boston-based school funding formula screws us over.) When the participating communities pay 50% of the cost of transport, THEN we can talk about how 'volunteer' it is.
Quickie response: As long as courts are not imposing quotas and ordering busing, Metco is still a fundamentally volunteer program. Both students and towns have a right to opt in or out. ... As for the seeming injustice of excluding non-blacks, sometimes you just have to look the other way when there's no great harm involved. Wish they did that with creches at Christmas. ... As for transportation costs, fix the reimbursement formula. ...